Gregory Friedman The Greg Wide Web on the name →

Essay · philosophy · politics

Contract Without Equals: Hierarchy and the Limits of Redistribution

Rousseau’s social contract is usually read as a defense of popular sovereignty. It is also something more demanding: a standard for deciding when political power counts as legitimate at all. That standard matters most where the state’s coercion is least disguised. Redistributive law openly compels people. Taxation, transfer, and regulation require citizens to carry material burdens on the ground that they belong to one political body and are not merely private persons who happen to share a map.

Rousseau can justify that kind of coercion, but only under a condition he states more clearly than his readers usually notice: the citizens subject to the law must stand toward one another as civic equals. My claim is that the absence of deep group hierarchy, whether racial or gendered, is a necessary condition for the social contract to legitimate redistributive state power. Where such hierarchy persists, the language of contract no longer names mutual self-legislation with any confidence. It begins instead to cover domination with the appearance of consent.

The argument points this way from its first move. Rousseau rejects the idea that legitimacy can come from power alone. “Force does not make right,” he writes, and so “one is only obliged to obey legitimate powers.” The point is simple and load-bearing: that some can command and others must obey does not, by itself, generate any obligation. Once force fails as a source of right, legitimacy has to come from agreement among the people bound by it.

He then frames the problem exactly. The task is to “find a form of association that will defend and protect the person and goods of each associate with the full common force, and by means of which each, uniting with all, nevertheless obey only himself and remain as free as before.” What matters here is not a founding moment of consent. It is a structural requirement. The association has to be arranged so that citizens can go on understanding the laws they obey as their own.

This is why the general will is such a strict test. Rousseau insists that “what generalizes the will is not so much the number of voices, as it is the common interest which unites them.” A large coalition can still be a faction, and a majority can still legislate for itself. To be general, a will has to be general twice over, in how it forms and in how it applies. Rousseau makes this explicit: the general will, “to be truly such, must issue from all in order to apply to all.”

Those two halves belong together, and each rules out a different failure. Issue from all excludes an order in which some groups are included in name while others set the terms of public life. Apply to all excludes laws that look universal on their face and serve sectional interests in practice. He presses the point further, holding that every legitimate act of sovereignty “either obligates or favors all Citizens equally.” Once a law targets or benefits a group as such, it stops being an act of the sovereign and becomes what he calls a “particular affair.”

Read this way, Rousseau does not demand social uniformity. He demands reciprocity. Citizens have to be able to recognize each other as both the authors and the addressees of law, which is why he says civic commitments bind only because they run both ways, so that in keeping them “one cannot work for others without also working for oneself.” That condition is what makes redistribution defensible inside his framework. Citizens can be required to contribute to a common good because the law is the act of a body of equals binding itself on the same terms. The coercion is still self-government.

The limit appears when reciprocal standing breaks down. Then the justification thins, and what looked like self-legislation starts to look like one group administering another.

Rousseau comes closer to this danger than he seems to realize. Writing on bad governments, he warns that equality can become “only apparent and illusory,” serving “only to keep the pauper in his poverty and the rich man in the position he has usurped,” and adds that “laws are always of use to those who possess and harmful to those who have nothing.” His immediate subject is wealth. The lesson generalizes. Once equality is merely apparent, legal universality no longer guarantees legitimacy: a law can go on speaking in the name of the whole while preserving an order in which some benefit and others are merely governed. If public equality has become illusory, the people are no longer meeting each other on the terms his own theory requires.

That is the opening the next three writers walk through.

Charles Mills shows what the problem looks like when race structures the political community. In The Racial Contract, he argues that white supremacy should be understood as a political system with its own logic of rule, privilege, and differential allocation of benefits and burdens, rather than as an accident or a lapse from contract theory’s ideals.

His sharpest claim is that the actual modern contract was never between everybody, “but between just the people who count, the people who really are people (‘we the white people’).” This is more than a historical accusation. It strikes directly at Rousseau’s requirement that the sovereign act issue from all. If the political “we” has already been racially bounded, then the formal vocabulary of citizenship conceals a prior exclusion. The polity can describe itself as universal while its universality has been racially coded from the start.

Mills goes further, and the further step is the one that matters here. The racial contract does not merely exclude; it builds a two-tiered moral and juridical order. He describes the European distinction between full humans and those treated as question-mark humans, and shows how colonial and slave legal systems codified “the subordinate status of nonwhites,” creating “a juridical space” for them “as a separate category of beings.”

This is fatal to the Rousseauian defense of redistribution, because that defense depends on equal civic recognition rather than on the mere existence of laws. If some people are legally or socially positioned as subpersons, common legislation is already compromised. The law stops expressing a relation among equals and starts expressing a relation between full participants and managed inferiors. Redistribution does not escape this. A racially ordered state can certainly tax and spend, and it can do so for serious moral reasons. Its redistributive coercion is still hard to describe as mutual self-legislation when the body imposing the burden was racially constituted before the burden was voted on.

Carole Pateman makes the parallel case about gender, and in doing so clarifies something Rousseau leaves underexplained. In The Sexual Contract, she argues that the familiar story contract theory tells is incomplete, because the freedom of the contracting individual rests on a prior structure of patriarchal subordination.

She puts it starkly: “Women are not party to the original contract through which men transform their natural freedom into the security of civil freedom.” Women are the subject of the contract, not a party to it. The force of the line is in that contrast. Rousseau’s citizen is both the author and the addressee of the law. Pateman’s reply is that, in the classical story, women are denied the double role. They enter civil society already marked by a relation of subordination rather than as free and equal contractors.

Her argument is useful here precisely because she refuses to treat patriarchy as a private defect sitting outside the political order. On her account, “patriarchal right extends throughout civil society,” and “civil freedom depends on patriarchal right.” That claim is what blocks the easy answer, which is to point at formal public equality and declare the problem solved. If the very idea of the independent contracting individual was built against a background of women’s subjection, then the public realm carries that bias inside it, and general laws can produce unequal outcomes without ever naming anyone.

The civic body, in other words, is constituted through a distinction between those understood as fit for civil freedom and those incorporated through dependence. Rousseau’s language about obeying only oneself becomes unstable at that point. When a class of persons is denied full standing as a maker of law, obedience can still occur. It no longer has the character he wants it to have, which is obedience to a law one can genuinely call one’s own.

Susan Moller Okin shows that the problem survives even a benevolent state, and even well-intentioned protection, when hierarchy persists inside the groups being protected. In Is Multiculturalism Bad for Women? she asks what should happen when claims for minority cultural rights collide with the equality of women.

Her concern complicates any easy picture of inclusion. A state can extend recognition to a cultural or religious minority and leave serious domination untouched, if the people authorized to speak for the group are not the people most burdened by its norms. Okin argues that liberal defenders of group rights too readily treat cultures as internally unified, when authority inside them is often distributed along steeply unequal gender lines. Hence her conclusion that “group rights are potentially, and in many cases actually, antifeminist.”

The resulting problem is layered. Women can be disadvantaged both in the wider state and by the internal power structure of the very group whose autonomy that state protects. Once that possibility is in view, formal inclusion looks far less secure. A woman can be counted as a member of the polity and still have no effective voice where decisions about family, custom, and authority are actually made. Equal civic standing therefore cannot be assessed at the level of public rights alone. It depends on whether the people recognized by law can participate as equals in the social worlds through which law operates. Where women are shut out of shaping the group claims advanced in their name, the protections that follow can leave them, as Okin puts it, “harmed rather than promoted” by those rights.

Okin’s contribution to this argument is to show that hierarchy can survive inside arrangements that look fair, pluralistic, and inclusive from the outside. That is the hardest case for Rousseau, because it is the case where nothing on the surface is wrong.

Plato helps name the political consequence of the pattern. When Socrates says that a city divided between rich and poor is not one city but two, he is doing more than noticing inequality. He is identifying a failure of political unity. A city whose members do not share a common good is fractured at the root, and justice becomes hard to achieve there because the whole is unstable.

The parallel to the general will is close. Disagreement does not destroy legitimacy; Rousseau never asked for consensus. Deep hierarchy does, because it produces a polity in which some live inside the civic body as full members while others are only partly admitted. In that situation appeals to the common good start to ring hollow. Plato’s observation generalizes what Mills, Pateman, and Okin each identify in a different register. A divided political community cannot easily speak in one sovereign voice, because in the relevant moral sense it is not one people.

The obvious objection is that plural, imperfect, visibly unequal societies do seem to sustain working social contracts. A contemporary defender of redistribution might argue that democratic procedure, constitutional protection, and a broad sense of social solidarity are enough. On that view, citizens who do not stand on fully equal social footing can still support redistribution through shared institutions and common political commitments.

This deserves to be taken seriously, because a standard that condemns every actual polity loses its practical force and becomes a way of saying nothing. But it does not touch the claim. The claim is not that legitimacy requires moral perfection, or the disappearance of social difference, or a society without conflict. It is narrower: legitimacy requires the absence of entrenched hierarchy that assigns some groups a lesser civic standing.

Put back in Rousseau’s own terms, this is a failure of reciprocity. When the law no longer “issues from all in order to apply to all,” the relation between citizen and law has changed in kind. Constitutional procedure can soften the defect, and redistribution can remain morally urgent on completely separate grounds, such as need. Neither observation answers the question of legitimacy in Rousseau’s sense. If racial personhood is stratified, if patriarchy structures civil freedom, or if supposedly inclusive accommodations silence the weaker members of recognized groups, then the law is the act of some over others. That is enough to defeat the claim that redistributive coercion is mutual self-legislation rather than managed subordination.

Rousseau’s theory turns out to be more radical than it first appears, and more radical than he seems to have intended. The social contract sets conditions on when the state’s pursuit of a common good can be legitimate, and those conditions reach further than he traced them. Mills, Pateman, and Okin are not refuting him. They are extending his model to the power structures he left out, and in doing so they identify the social realities that keep his own standard from being met.

Where racial or gendered hierarchy blocks equal civic recognition, the general will cannot exist in the form he demands, because it does not genuinely issue from all or bind all as equals. In those conditions contract language becomes ideological. It lends the appearance of shared authorship to an order still organized by domination. The absence of deep hierarchy is therefore not a happy addition to Rousseau’s contract theory. It is a condition of the thing working at all.

Sources

  • Mills, Charles W. The Racial Contract. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1997.
  • Okin, Susan Moller. “Is Multiculturalism Bad for Women?” In Is Multiculturalism Bad for Women?, edited by Joshua Cohen, Matthew Howard, and Martha C. Nussbaum. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1999.
  • Pateman, Carole. The Sexual Contract. Cambridge: Polity Press, 1988.
  • Plato. Republic. Translated by G. M. A. Grube, revised by C. D. C. Reeve. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing, 1992.
  • Rousseau, Jean-Jacques. “The Social Contract.” In The Social Contract and Other Later Political Writings, edited and translated by Victor Gourevitch. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997.

Quotations from Rousseau, Mills, and Okin follow the pagination of Zwolinski, Miller, and Tomasi, eds., How Can the State Be Justified? and Does Justice Require Equality? (New York: Oxford University Press, 2016), where these texts are excerpted.

Written for PHIL 1104 at the University of Connecticut. The argument is unchanged; the footnotes have been consolidated into the source list above.

Keys on this page

A figure's keys are its own: they answer once the figure has focus, so tab to it or click it first. Esc closes this sheet.