Gregory Friedman The Greg Wide Web on the name →

Essay · anthropology · economics · coursework

Debt and Dessert: Economic Exploitation in the Caribbean

For the past half millennium, the Caribbean region has been emblematic of the negative effects of the global trends of European colonialism, neocolonialism, and neoliberalism. The vast majority of the indigenous Taíno people were wiped out due to a combination of Eurasian diseases and chattel slavery. In order to continue the exploitation of the Caribbean, which was ideal for growing cash crops such as sugar, coffee, and cocoa for the growing European bourgeois class, Western European nation-states imported millions of Sub-Saharan Africans to replace continuously diminishing indigenous labor as part of the Transatlantic Slave Trade, a brutal campaign of ethnic cleansing in support of capitalist profit (Roden 2016). Even after the waves of decolonization that occurred in the 19th and 20th centuries, these young, black-majority nations were forced into a system of neoliberalism and global capitalism which primarily benefitted their former colonizers and perpetuated the problems of immiseration and underdevelopment. To further explain this continuity in power dynamics even after the official end of colonization and slavery, I reviewed two documentaries on the post-colonial economies of the Caribbean: “Life and Debt” and “Nothing Like Chocolate.” I argue that although both documentaries persuasively convey their messages, “Life and Debt” primarily highlights the problems caused by neoliberalism, whereas “Nothing Like Chocolate” focuses on a feasible alternative to the current global capitalist status quo.

“Life and Debt” focuses on the economic problems facing the Jamaican economy following its independence from Great Britain in 1962, particularly in the context of neoliberalism and the hegemony of international financial institutions. Specifically, the documentary focuses on the impact of the policies imposed by the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank, notably the removal of protectionist tariffs and subsidies, cuts to education and healthcare spending, and the establishment of the Jamaican free zone. The liberalization of trade imposed by the multinational financial institutions led to the gutting of industries essential for domestic self-reliance, the dairy, poultry, and banana industries among them; these were replaced by cheaper, subsidized products from the Global North at the behest of transnational corporations.

The documentary explores these themes by interdigitating interviews with notable figures such as the professor of economics Michael Witter, the former Prime Minister of Jamaica Michael Manley, and the director of the International Monetary Fund Stanley Fischer. Each of these people has a distinct perspective on the causes of and solutions for Jamaica’s economic woes, giving the documentary an air of credibility by providing multiple conflicting points of view from knowledgeable sources. Footage of local farmers and citizens is included, which adds to the authenticity of the documentary. Footage of tourists is interspliced with scenes of the locals to show the disparity between the rich, white tourists and the impoverished, predominantly black population. These interviews with experts and the footage of both locals and tourists serve to further the message of the documentary and reinforce the emotional charge of the narrative, showing the poverty in which the average Jamaican lives compared to the care-free lives of the tourists from the Global North.

“Life and Debt” adequately and powerfully identifies the economic challenges that Jamaica faced in the final quarter of the 20th century and continues to face to this day. The documentary shows qualitative evidence for this throughout the film, and this is corroborated by external academic reports, one of which shows that interest payments on debt accounted for 41.2% of total government expenditure in 2001, the year the documentary was produced (Johnston and Montecino 2010). This gross misallocation of financial capital indirectly supports the documentary’s claims of forced payment of debt and interest in lieu of funding for education and healthcare.

The documentary does an excellent job in conveying the mood of workers in the Jamaican free zone. The Jamaican free zone is a special economic zone that forgoes certain taxes and regulations on foreign transnational corporations to spur investment in Jamaica. However, this often leads to the exploitation of workers who receive few protections from arbitrary firing, suppressed wages, and the withholding of already earned wages. Furthermore, the free zone led to a sense of loss of sovereignty, as the area is heavily guarded and Jamaicans require special documents to enter an area of their own, supposedly independent, nation.

The scene beginning at 50 minutes, 20 seconds depicts workers, predominantly women of color, entering the Jamaican free zone and passing through the stringent security checkpoints. In this scene, none of the workers were shown smiling; a uniform, defeated frown was worn by the entire cohort. The black-and-white color emphasizes the banal and dehumanizing aspects of life in the free zones. Furthermore, the inclusion of the Bob Marley song “Work” played over the scene reinforces this message, as this song cynically counts down the days left of work, indicating an unfulfilling system of labor. Bob Marley is a famous Jamaican peacemaker and musician; his message was thoroughly one of anti-colonialism and the liberation of all peoples. Including this artist pays homage to the anti-colonial underpinnings of much of Jamaican culture, as well as to the cultural icon himself. At the end of the scene, color is restored and a sign stating “All persons entering and leaving the Kingston free zone are subject to be searched” furthers the theme of a lack of sovereignty in one’s own country and of dehumanizing working conditions. The next scene explains the specific, quotidian realities of workers in the Kingston free zone, which connects smoothly with the analyzed scene.

Although “Life and Debt” does an adequate job in identifying the key problems of the Jamaican economy and their connections with foreign imposed financial policies, such as deregulation and surrender to the demands of international financial institutions, the documentary fails to provide enough context on certain historical events relevant to its contents. Although the documentary introduces Michael Manley as a former Prime Minister of Jamaica, there is scant information about his politics and his role in Jamaican history and political development. Manley served three terms as the Prime Minister of Jamaica and had become one of the most popular politicians in Jamaican history. As a left-leaning trade unionist, his policies focused on the redistribution of land and capital, as well as on increasing ties with Communist countries such as Cuba and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, which led to a decrease in aid from the United States and other capitalist nations. These actions inform the later economic distress of Jamaica, as it was cut off from a substantial amount of foreign aid due to its participation in the Non-Aligned Movement, which sought to cooperate with both sides of the first Cold War (Britannica 2024). Having a deeper understanding of Jamaica’s position in the geopolitical order would allow for a more holistic analysis of the power dynamics involved between the Global North and many Caribbean nations.

Whereas “Life and Debt” provides an apt description of many of the economic pitfalls befalling a particular Caribbean nation due to the trends of global capitalism and neoliberalism, “Nothing Like Chocolate” discusses a potential solution for another impoverished Caribbean former colony, Grenada. In the documentary, the Grenada Chocolate Company, founded by the American anarchist Mott Green, is discussed in detail. The distinction of the Grenada Chocolate Company, as compared to most chocolate companies, is its desire to uphold the highest ethical and environmental standards. The company is structured as a cooperative, meaning that all members of the corporation are paid the same amount, leading to better outcomes for Grenadian natives as compared to the traditional, hierarchical corporate structures of cocoa companies. In fact, this novel economic structure means that the Grenadian farmer is paid two dollars per pound of wet cocoa, as opposed to approximately $1.25 for traditional sale methods (Bhavnani 2012). In addition to decreasing the inequality between members of the corporation, the Grenada Chocolate Company is structured to be vertically integrated, meaning that all steps of the supply chain, from farming to the distinct phases of processing, are done by the same company. This increases efficiency and, more importantly, creates more opportunity for value-added labor to be done in Grenada as opposed to in places in the Global North.

Although many chocolates, and crops more generally, are claimed to be grown organically, this movement seldom includes the exploited laborers of the Global South who are not included in the “sustainability” craze. For example, the plurality of raw cocoa is grown in the West African country of Côte d’Ivoire, where child slavery is frequently utilized to harvest the cocoa plant. These gross human rights abuses are often obscured by myriad shell companies and intermediary suppliers, which supply transnational corporations such as Nestlé and Hershey with a veneer of innocence, and in turn allow them to maintain a positive image with the public while continuing to exploit children to maximize profits.

“Nothing Like Chocolate” elaborates on a particular solution to the socioeconomic woes of those in Caribbean island nations, specifically Grenada in the case of this documentary. In a scene starting at 46 minutes and 54 seconds, Green explains how the current fair trade certification system, which attempts to create an equitable solution, is dysfunctional and instead enriches the intermediate entities in the trade of cocoa, not the actual farmers and laborers at the “bottom” of the supply chain. The collage of snapshots and snippets of video depicting the process of harvesting and processing the cocoa, in which both Green and the local Grenadians participate, enhances the spirit of comradery and equality between different members of the organization. Furthermore, the lack of music in this scene increases the focus on his message, which is that the current systems in place for the distribution of capital are inadequate to satisfy the needs of those from the Global South (Bhavnani 2012).

Despite adequately presenting and arguing for a solution to the economic woes faced by Caribbean nations due to neoliberalism and global capitalism, “Nothing Like Chocolate,” like “Life and Debt,” fails to fully explain the historical and political context of the island nation. For example, although Maurice Bishop is briefly mentioned in the documentary, his role in leading a Marxist-Leninist government of Grenada was not elaborated upon. Following intense infighting between factions of the ruling communist government, the Reagan administration took the opportunity, while the island nation was divided and destabilized, to invade and depose the government, replacing it with one more favorable to American and capitalist interests. The history of Grenada, especially in recent decades, has been heavily influenced by the struggle with capitalism and neocolonialism. Although the documentary references these themes, the omission of this important historical information decreases the credibility and cohesion of the argument.

In conclusion, both “Life and Debt” and “Nothing Like Chocolate” focus on the economic situation in specific Caribbean island nations in response to neoliberalism and global capitalism. While “Life and Debt” focuses on the Jamaican economy and mostly outlines the problems associated with neoliberal financial policy, such as ballooning national debt and the loss of economic independence, “Nothing Like Chocolate” focuses on Grenada and offers a viable alternative: vertical integration of the supply chain and a novel, more equitable corporate structure. Although I would recommend that the reader watch both films, as they provide a unique perspective on these beautiful island nations, on the exploitation of their land and people, and on their reactions to it, both documentaries fail to discuss the geopolitical context of these countries, something which would provide a more holistic understanding of their current economic and political situation.

Sources

  • Baksh, A. L. “Forward Ever: 40 Years on from the End of the Revolution and the U.S. Invasion of Grenada.” NACLA, October 24, 2023.
  • Bhavnani, Kum-Kum, dir. Nothing Like Chocolate. Bullfrog Films, 2012.
  • Black, Stephanie, dir. Life and Debt. New York: New Yorker Films, 2001.
  • Encyclopædia Britannica. “Michael Manley.” April 26, 2024.
  • Johnston, J., and J. A. Montecino. “Jamaica: Macroeconomic Policy, Debt and the IMF.” Center for Economic and Policy Research, 2011.
  • LeMay, J. “About the Film.” Nothing Like Chocolate, a film by Kum-Kum Bhavnani, 2024.
  • Roden, I. “The Caribbean Indigenous Legacies Project: Celebrating Taíno Culture.” Smithsonian Office of Global Affairs, March 8, 2016.
  • Urken, R. K. “How Grenada Is Turning Itself into a Chocolate Destination.” Condé Nast Traveler, May 19, 2023.

Written for ANTH 1000W at the University of Connecticut, summer 2024, as a comparative review of two assigned documentaries. Reproduced here as argued then, with typographic cleanup and a tidied bibliography, and nothing added. The one substantive correction: the Johnston and Montecino report is dated 2011 in the bibliography and was cited as 2010 in the body, and the director’s name is Bhavnani rather than Bhavani.

Keys on this page

A figure's keys are its own: they answer once the figure has focus, so tab to it or click it first. Esc closes this sheet.