Gregory Friedman The Greg Wide Web on the name →

Essay · anthropology · technology · coursework

iPhorgot the Consequences: Defamiliarization of the iPhone

Over the past two decades, the iPhone has sold over 1.5 billion units worldwide, dramatically affecting the anthropological and economic landscape of both the Global North and South (Laricchia 2024). Although the iPhone is a near ubiquitous product in Global North markets such as the United States and Europe, the device’s externalities have outsized impacts on the Global South, where a significant portion of the population cannot benefit from this technology. This essay will investigate the impact of the iPhone on individuals involved in various parts of the supply chain, specifically lithium miners in the Lithium Triangle region of South America, factory workers in the Foxconn Shenzhen factory, and iPhone consumers in the United States. Among each population, I argue that the iPhone has led to substantial environmental degradation and social alienation.

The production of the iPhone is an incredible feat of globalization. Due to the advanced systems of neoliberal capitalism, raw inputs are sourced from dozens of countries around the globe, manufactured in others, then shipped to tertiary nations for consumption. The first step of the iPhone supply chain is the mining of minerals, notably rare earth metals, which are indispensable for applications in electronics and circuitry. As a complex work of electrical, chemical and mechanical engineering, the iPhone’s manufacturing requires myriad mineral inputs. In particular, the elements carbon, yttrium, gallium, silver, indium and tantalum are currently being used at an unsustainable rate in the smartphone industry, with risks of depletion within the coming century. Furthermore, carbon, tungsten, tantalum, gold and tin are all mineral inputs originating in countries plagued by ongoing armed conflicts, and thus their extraction is linked with the continued fueling of that violence (European Chemical Society 2022). The most critical elemental input to the production of the iPhone, however, is lithium.

Lithium serves as the cation for the rechargeable batteries found in nearly all consumer electronics, including Apple products, and most of the world’s supply of this mineral is mined in a region of South America known as the Lithium Triangle. This area encompasses the border regions of Bolivia, Argentina, and Chile. The region lies at the intersection of the Andes mountain range and the Atacama Desert, which has historically been home to indigenous communities such as the Atacameño and Aymara peoples. These indigenous communities have borne the brunt of the negative externalities of lithium mining. The Colla tribe of the Atacameño people is a group indigenous to northern Chile, specifically to the regions where large tracts of lithium were discovered. Due to this mining, the Colla’s traditional religious and spiritual beliefs, which center on the divinity of Pachamama (the Earth Mother), have been defiled. By being pushed off their lands, the Colla have been separated from an integral part of their culture, and alienated from their traditional, nomadic way of life, which often involved seasonal rituals in reverence of Pachamama (Greenfield 2022).

Along with the destruction of their ancestral homeland, indigenous communities in the Lithium Triangle face overlapping environmental challenges. The primary method for extraction of lithium in this region is the systematic drying of salt flats. This is done by pumping out the mineral-rich brine from underneath the salt flats, which leaves the solid minerals, mainly lithium, readily available for extraction (Barandiarán 2018). This industrial process often leads to water loss, groundwater and soil contamination, and ground destabilization. Furthermore, the power imbalance between indigenous communities and transnational corporations condones abuse of power by these companies. In the case of Atacameño communities in Chile, they “sell precious water resources to the companies but do so in the context of relying on the companies to provide information on the environmental impacts of extracting subterranean water resources” (Jacka 2018, 69). Under the doctrine of neoliberalism, Global South countries are often encouraged to sell the rights to mine in certain mineral-rich areas to multinational corporations. These companies often have little incentive to respect the rights and desires of indigenous peoples, and often work in tandem with national governments “to develop lithium deposits; they … trample on the rights and health of communities, particularly indigenous ones, living near salt flat” (Barandiarán 2018, 386).

In addition to exploitation of mineral resources by transnational corporations, many indigenous peoples in this region, and more broadly in the Global South, are employed in what is known as artisanal and small-scale mining (ASM), which often leads to negative health outcomes. These artisanal miners are often sidelined by the government as “illegal” due to their informal nature and in opposition to the mining concessions given to foreign multinationals. In the case of indigenous Bolivians employed in artisanal and small-scale mining, high concentrations of mercury were found in the blood of the artisanal miners, likely due to runoff from mineral brine into local rivers (Jacka 2018). Due to the lack of capital supplied from global markets for ASM, the working conditions in artisanal mines are abysmal and regulations are seldom enforced. The demand for minerals created by the Global North, whether supplied by multinational mining companies or directly by indigenous peoples, massively impacts the health of their bodies and their ancestral homeland.

Once the raw materials are extracted from the Earth, they are then shipped to secondary countries, primarily in East and Southeast Asia, for manufacturing. High-end electronic components, such as accelerometers and GPUs, which allow for the complex computations and high efficiency of the modern iPhone, are primarily manufactured in industrialized East Asian countries such as Japan, Taiwan and South Korea (Wankhede 2024). However, most of the manufacturing process occurs in the People’s Republic of China, where hundreds of thousands of predominantly Han Chinese laborers are tasked with assembling the different components of the iPhone. Apple outsources the work of manufacturing to the Taiwanese industrial conglomerate Foxconn, whose largest factory is found on the periphery of the Chinese coastal city of Shenzhen, colloquially referred to as “iPod City”, and can house close to half a million workers at any given time (Qiu et al 2014). Many of these workers are migrants from the more impoverished interior in search of economic opportunities.

Under the Hukou system, which sets draconian criteria for internal migration between Chinese provinces and makes many rural-to-urban migrants into de facto second class citizens, many Foxconn workers are not afforded the rights of a legal citizen of Shenzhen. Taking advantage of these migrant workers’ precarious economic situation, Foxconn has created a gigantic factory that also houses these workers, in poor and cramped conditions, under the same roof as where they work (Yang and Gallagher 2017). Despite the initial motivation of migrants from the interior to the relatively more prosperous coastal regions, dehumanizing working conditions in Foxconn’s “iPod City” have had a dangerous impact on the wellbeing of workers: “The ruthlessness and inhumanity of the labor process, determined in classic Taylorist fashion … still constitutes much of the production process in this iPhone era, as in Foxconn” (Qiu et al 2014, 571). Taylorism is the capitalist practice of management which aims to maximize labor productivity, without regard for the workers’ conditions. This mentality is reflected in the lack of legally enshrined workers’ rights and a “notorious ‘military-style’ management system” (Qiu et al 2014, 573), which in turn has contributed to horrific incidences of suicide, culminating in 2010 when 14 workers were confirmed deceased after jumping out of the windows of the massive complex (Maharani and Mursitama 2023). The corporate solution to these tragic deaths was the installation of nets outside of the windows to prevent successful suicide attempts, a sight which was propagated into the international spotlight ironically by the same iPhones these workers were producing (Merchant 2017).

In addition to many workers’ rights violations, Foxconn, and thus indirectly Apple, has been accused of using local rivers as dumping grounds for toxic heavy metal byproducts released during the manufacturing process. Speaking on the condition of anonymity, villagers living alongside one of these tributary rivers remarked that “We used to catch cuttlefish there, and it was so clear we could see a meter down … [Now, even] if my hands were dirty, I wouldn’t wash them in this water” (Myslewski 2013).

Once the iPhone is assembled and packaged in Asia, it is typically sent to the tertiary country, where it is sold. However, even during consumption, the same general trends follow all those touched by the iPhone supply chain: environmental degradation and social alienation. I will focus on iPhone consumption in the United States for the sake of simplicity, though similar trends apply to iPhone consumption in other countries.

Despite the willing mass consumption of the iPhone, the widescale adoption of the device has led to increased rates of anxiety and depression, especially among children who have grown up with the devices since childhood, known as digital natives. Since screen time is an indicator of depression among all age groups, and as increased screen time is normalized, there has been a dramatic increase in rates of adolescent depression over the past decade (Li et al 2022). Since social interaction is an integral part of any human society, the increase in cyber-socialization in lieu of physical socialization can be argued to contribute to the substantial uptick in rates of depression among younger generations in regions where iPhone consumption is commonplace.

In addition to the damaging effects on the mental health of children, iPhones are manufactured per the doctrine of planned obsolescence, which aims to increase product turnover rate unnecessarily and thus increase product volume and revenue. When surveyed, most iPhone users report that they have owned one to three iPhones before settling on their current model (Rodriguez et al 2015). The planned obsolescence of iPhones has led to the proliferation of e-waste. The toxic heavy metals needed for the proper functioning of the advanced integrated circuits found in modern smartphones often leach into local waterways and soil after disposal. Furthermore, the intentionally shortened life cycle of iPhones has led to a needless increase in rare earth metal mining and in greenhouse gas emissions from the production and transportation of these products.

It is important to note that Apple and other large multinational corporations use certain strategies to shift blame for environmental and societal harm onto other organizations and groups within the global capitalist system. For example, when Foxconn abuses workers and pollutes the environment, Apple has the plausible deniability to deny allegations of human rights abuses and environmental contamination. Similarly, Apple does not directly steal land from the indigenous peoples of the Atacama Desert; it relies on contracted mining companies to “extract” the raw materials.

In conclusion, throughout the breadth of the iPhone supply chain, the impact of this technology can be felt on societies globally and across the lifecycle of the product, although this impact is not uniformly distributed. Whether with respect to the miners, factory workers, or consumers, the iPhone tends to lead to environmental degradation and social alienation. Moreover, the negative externalities of the iPhone are distributed disproportionately onto indigenous populations and those in the Global South. This uneven distribution of consequences is enabled by a system of globalized capitalism where exploitation of economically and politically disadvantaged peoples is rewarded. Multinational corporations are encouraged to commodify people in order to minimize the costs of producing commodities. Given that iPhones and smartphones now play an integral role in our contemporary society, it is imperative that the anthropological effects of the entire lifecycle of the iPhone are understood.

Sources

  • Barandiarán, Javiera. “Lithium and Development Imaginaries in Chile, Argentina and Bolivia.” World Development, October 4, 2018.
  • Bold, Rosalyn. “On Bolivian Lithium.” Society for Cultural Anthropology, March 24, 2020.
  • European Chemical Society. “The EuChemS Periodic Table and Rare Elements in Consumer Electronics (Smartphones).” March 11, 2022.
  • Greenfield, Nicole. “Lithium Mining Is Leaving Chile’s Indigenous Communities High and Dry (Literally).” Natural Resources Defense Council, April 26, 2022.
  • Jacka, Jerry K. “The Anthropology of Mining: The Social and Environmental Impacts of Resource Extraction in the Mineral Age.” Annual Review of Anthropology, October 21, 2018.
  • Laricchia, Federica. “Apple iPhone Revenue by Quarter 2024.” Statista, May 17, 2024.
  • Li, Liqing, Qi Zhang, Liyong Zhu, Guohua Zeng, Hongwei Huang, Jian Zhuge, Xiaorui Kuang, et al. “Screen Time and Depression Risk: A Meta-Analysis of Cohort Studies.” Frontiers in Psychiatry, December 22, 2022.
  • Maharani, Desty, and Tirta Nugraha Mursitama. “Implementing Ethical ‘Code of Work Ethics’: A Case Study of the Apple and Foxconn Supply Chain.” E3S Web of Conferences, 2023.
  • Merchant, Brian. “Life and Death in Apple’s Forbidden City.” The Guardian, June 18, 2017.
  • Myslewski, Rik. “Chinese Apple Suppliers Face Toxic Heavy Metal Water Pollution Charges.” The Register, August 5, 2013.
  • Qiu, Jack Linchuan, Melissa Gregg, and Kate Crawford. “Circuits of Labour: A Labour Theory of the iPhone Era.” TripleC 12, no. 2 (September 1, 2014).
  • Rodriguez, Emely, Odemaris Carrasquillo, Christopher Lee, Jon Lee, and Angela Zhou. “iGo Green: A Life Cycle Assessment of Apple’s iPhone.” March 15, 2015.
  • Wankhede, Calvin. “Where Is the iPhone Made? The Journey from Components to Final Assembly.” Android Authority, April 17, 2024.
  • Yang, Yujeong, and Mary Gallagher. “Moving In and Moving Up? Labor Conditions and China’s Changing Development Model.” Wiley Online Library, July 5, 2017.

Written for ANTH 1000W at the University of Connecticut, summer 2024, as a defamiliarization exercise: take an object so ordinary it has stopped being visible, and follow it back through its supply chain until it looks strange again. Reproduced here as argued then, with typographic cleanup and a tidied bibliography, and nothing added.

Keys on this page

A figure's keys are its own: they answer once the figure has focus, so tab to it or click it first. Esc closes this sheet.